Can you mix AirPods? Pairing a replacement or two different earbuds
Same-model AirPods can be paired into a set with Apple's replacement steps; mixed generations trigger a mismatch alert. How to check and how to pair.
Written by the YOONIG team · Updated · 7 min read

Same model, yes. Different generations, no
You can pair two AirPods that didn't come together as long as they're the same model: that's exactly what happens when Apple sends a replacement for a lost earbud. You can't mix generations. Put an AirPods Pro 2 earbud in a case with an AirPods Pro 1 earbud, or a 2nd generation AirPod with a 3rd, and your iPhone shows a Mismatched AirPods alert instead of connecting them.
Apple lists three situations that trigger that alert: the AirPods in the charging case are different generations, the AirPods in the case belong to someone else, or the mismatch shows up in Find My (Apple: If you get an alert that says Mismatched AirPods). For the first, its advice is to identify your AirPods and work out which models belong in that case. For a same-model replacement, there's a pairing routine that takes about 25 minutes, most of it waiting.
Which combinations work
Most questions about mixing fall into one of these cases.
| What you're trying to do | Result | What to do |
|---|---|---|
| Replacement left or right AirPod of the same model, with your original case | Works after setup | Run Apple's replacement steps (below) |
| Your two AirPods in a replacement case of the same model | Works after setup | Same replacement steps |
| Earbuds from two different generations in one case | Mismatched AirPods alert | Identify both earbuds and put the right pair back together |
| Your AirPod and a friend's AirPod of the same model, swapped by accident | Both of you get an AirPods Mismatch alert | Use Find My to play a sound, find your own and swap back |
| An AirPod that's still linked to another person's Apple Account | AirPods Mismatch in Find My | The other person must remove it from their Apple Account first |
| AirPods in a different model's charging case | Not supported | A charging case has to match the AirPods model |
Check that the two earbuds really match
Lookalikes are the trap. AirPods 1 and 2 share the same charging cases, and Apple lists identical earbud dimensions for AirPods Pro 1 and Pro 2. The reliable check is the model number: Apple prints it on the underside of each AirPod, in tiny text that starts with the letter A (Apple: Identify your AirPods). Apple lists two or three earbud numbers for each model, so the two in your hand don't have to be identical: both should appear in the same row of the table.
If the print has worn off, connect the AirPods and look in Settings, Bluetooth, then the More Info button next to them. The full walk-through is in which AirPods you have.
Two rows deserve care. AirPods 4 and AirPods 4 with Active Noise Cancellation have different earbud model numbers, and so do the Lightning and USB-C versions of AirPods Pro 2. Apple doesn't publish a statement on mixing earbuds across those pairs, so don't buy a loose earbud on the assumption that it will work. Match the row.
| AirPods model | Earbud model numbers | Year |
|---|---|---|
| AirPods (1st generation) | A1523, A1722 | 2016 |
| AirPods (2nd generation) | A2032, A2031 | 2019 |
| AirPods (3rd generation) | A2565, A2564 | 2021 |
| AirPods 4 | A3053, A3050, A3054 | 2024 |
| AirPods 4 with Active Noise Cancellation | A3056, A3055, A3057 | 2024 |
| AirPods 5 | A3531, A3532, A3533 | 2026 |
| AirPods 5 with Wireless Charging Case | A3439, A3440, A3441 | 2026 |
| AirPods Pro (1st generation) | A2084, A2083 | 2019 |
| AirPods Pro 2 (Lightning case) | A2931, A2699, A2698 | 2022 |
| AirPods Pro 2 (USB-C case) | A3047, A3048, A3049 | 2023 |
| AirPods Pro 3 | A3063, A3064, A3065 | 2025 |
Pair a new replacement AirPod with the one you still have
A replacement earbud doesn't work the moment it arrives. It has to be introduced to the other earbud and the case, and Apple's routine for that starts with a long charge (Apple: Set up your replacement AirPods or charging case). Don't skip the wait.
- Put both AirPods, the old one and the new one, in the charging case.
- Connect the case to power, close the lid and wait 20 minutes.
- Open the lid. If the status light flashes white, skip the next two steps.
- If it doesn't, on AirPods 1, 2 and 3 and AirPods Pro 1 and 2: press and hold the setup button on the back of the case for about 15 seconds, until the light flashes amber, then white.
- On AirPods 4, AirPods 5 and AirPods Pro 3 instead: double-tap the front of the case, then again and a third time as the light changes, until it flashes amber, then white.
- With the light flashing white, close the lid.
- On your iPhone or iPad, open Settings, then Bluetooth. If your AirPods are in the list, tap the info button next to them, tap Forget This Device and confirm.
- Go to the Home Screen and open the lid of the case next to the iPhone or iPad.
- Tap Connect on the setup animation, then Done.
If the replacement still won't pair, or only one side plays
Start again from the charge. The 20 minutes on power with the lid closed is part of the procedure, not a suggestion, so keep the case plugged in throughout. If the light never reaches white, close the lid for 20 seconds, open it and repeat the button hold or the double-taps; the detail for each model is in how to reset AirPods.
If the pair connects but one earbud is silent, Apple's check is specific: put both in the case for 30 seconds, open it near the iPhone, confirm on screen that each AirPod is charging, then test the quiet one on its own with the other left in the closed case. When that fails after a recent replacement, Apple sends you back to the replacement setup steps above.
Still stuck after two clean attempts: confirm the model numbers once more, then contact Apple Support. An earbud from another generation isn't meant to pass this setup, however many times you run it.
When the alert appears and nothing was replaced
The second and third causes on Apple's list have nothing to do with hardware. If you and a friend own the same model and your earbuds got swapped at the gym or on a desk, Apple says both of you receive an AirPods Mismatch alert. Use Find My to locate your missing AirPod and play a sound on it to tell which one is yours.
The Find My version of the alert appears when you try to pair AirPods that are already paired to a different Apple Account. AirPods can be associated with only one Apple Account for Find My, so the previous user has to remove them from theirs before they'll behave as yours. This is the common snag with secondhand single earbuds.
If one of yours is simply gone and Find My can't locate it, Apple's page says you can get a replacement from Apple Support. Our guide to finding a lost AirPods case covers the Find My steps that apply to earbuds as well.
While you wait, and what a replacement means for your case and cover
You don't have to stop listening while a replacement is on its way: one earbud plays on its own, as explained in using AirPods with one earbud.
Mixing cases is a separate question from mixing earbuds. A case has to match the AirPods model too, and a new case goes through the same pairing steps: see charging AirPods in a different case. If the case itself is what you lost, replacing a lost or broken AirPods case goes through the options.
A replacement earbud changes nothing about the cover you use, because the cover is shaped to the charging case, not to the earbuds. A replacement case of the same model and version takes the same cover. Only moving to a different AirPods model means a different cover: we print a separate hard shell for each model, listed under AirPods cases.
Frequently asked questions
Can you use two different AirPods together?
Yes if both are the same model, after running Apple's replacement setup: 20 minutes in the powered case with the lid closed, then pairing mode and Connect. Earbuds from different generations trigger a Mismatched AirPods alert.
How do I pair two different AirPods of the same model?
Put both in the case, connect it to power, close the lid and wait 20 minutes. Open the lid and, if the light isn't flashing white, hold the setup button for about 15 seconds (or double-tap the case three times on AirPods 4, AirPods 5 and AirPods Pro 3). Forget the old AirPods in Bluetooth settings, open the lid by your iPhone and tap Connect.
Can I mix AirPods Pro 1 and AirPods Pro 2 earbuds?
No. They're different generations, which is the first cause Apple lists for the Mismatched AirPods alert. Check the model number under each earbud: A2084 and A2083 are AirPods Pro 1.
What does AirPods Mismatch mean?
Apple shows it when the AirPods in the case are different generations, when one of them belongs to someone else, or in Find My when AirPods are already paired to another Apple Account.
Can I buy just one AirPod?
Apple's mismatch page says that if you can't find a missing AirPod you can get a replacement from Apple Support. Once it arrives, it has to be set up with your remaining AirPod and case before it works.
Do left and right AirPods have the same model number?
Not necessarily. Apple lists two or three earbud model numbers for each model, for example A2565 and A2564 for AirPods (3rd generation). What matters is that both of yours belong to the same model in Apple's list.
Shop the story
- Orange Gingham AirPods caseFrom$29.00AirPods case · choose your model
- Baby Blue AirPods caseFrom$29.00AirPods case · choose your model
- Daisy Flower AirPods caseFrom$29.00AirPods case · choose your model






