Skip to content
Buying guide

What makes a phone case protective: four features that do the work

A protective case is a design, not a material: raised edges, a soft layer under a hard one, cushioned corners and a guarded camera. Here is how to check for each.

Written by the YOONIG team · Updated · 7 min read

Close-up of a phone case corner with a raised lip around the camera and a visible inner layer

Yes, cases protect, and four design features do most of it

A case protects a phone when it does four things: keeps the glass off flat surfaces with raised edges, puts a soft layer under a hard one, cushions the corners, and guards the camera. Material names and marketing labels matter far less than whether those features are present. A case with none of them is a scratch cover, which is still useful, but it's a different product.

There's no single best phone case, because the best one depends on how your phone gets hurt. What you can do is check any case, ours included, against the same short list. The rest of this page is that list, with the reasons behind it.

The benchmark Apple sets for case makers

Apple publishes design rules for companies that make accessories for its devices, and the section on cases is short and specific. It says a case shall protect the device from a 1 m drop onto a hard paved surface in any orientation. It says exposed glass shall not come within 0.85 mm of a flat surface with the case on, ideally 1.00 mm, and that this should be achieved with features around the glass (Apple: Accessory Design Guidelines).

The same document covers things shoppers rarely think about. A case must not scratch or damage the phone through repeated insertion and removal. Its dyes and inks must not transfer onto the phone or the user, including when in contact with water, hand sanitizer, sunscreen or lotion. It must not interfere with the compass or with camera autofocus and optical image stabilization.

Two cautions about using this as a yardstick. It's written for iPhone accessory makers, though the physics is the same for a Galaxy or a Pixel. And it describes what a case should do, not what any particular case has been shown to do. We don't publish a drop-test rating for our cases, and we aren't going to borrow Apple's figure as if it were a result of ours.

Raised edges: the feature that saves glass

Glass cracks or scratches when it meets something hard and flat, or something small and gritty lying on a flat surface. A lip that stands above the screen and around the camera means the case touches down first. This is the 0.85 mm idea from Apple's guidelines in practical form.

You can check it in ten seconds. Put the phone face down on a table and look at it from the side: there should be a visible gap between glass and tabletop. Do the same on its back and look at the lenses. If the lens rings are the first thing to touch, the case isn't guarding them.

In our range, the Tough build is specified with raised camera and screen edges. The Slim build's edge is slight, which is the cost of keeping it thin. Our comparison of Tough and Slim cases goes into that trade.

Two layers: one to give, one to hold

A drop is over in a moment, and what hurts the phone is how sudden the stop is and how concentrated the force. A soft layer lengthens the stop by compressing. A stiff layer spreads the load so it doesn't all arrive at one point. One material can't be both soft and stiff, which is why protective cases are usually built from two.

That's the construction of our Tough cases: a polycarbonate outer shell that the maker says resists daily impacts, over a TPU liner that absorbs shock. The MagSafe compatible build uses the same two layers with a magnetic module added. A one-piece hard shell or a one-piece soft case does half of the job each; we cover the soft half in are silicone phone cases protective.

Corners and the camera: where phones land and what sticks out

When a phone lands on a corner, it lands on the smallest contact patch it has, so the force there is at its most concentrated. Extra material or an air pocket at the corners gives that force somewhere to go before it reaches the frame.

The camera is the other weak point, because on most current phones it stands out from the back. A case can deal with that in two ways: a raised rim around a cut-out, or a surround that is part of the case frame itself. The second is how our MagSafe + camera guard build is made. Its TPU frame has the camera area built in, and the maker lists rugged, air-cushioned corners with reinforced bumpers. It exists for iPhone Pro models only: iPhone 16 Pro, 17 Pro, 17 Pro Max, 18 Pro and 18 Pro Max, for example on the iPhone 17 Pro cases page.

A surround protects the lens area from flat contact and side knocks. It doesn't cover the lens glass itself, so a pointed object can still reach it. Whether that's worth an extra layer is a separate question, covered in do you need a camera lens protector.

How our builds score on the four features

Here's the checklist applied to our own range, using only what the maker's specification states. An entry of not stated means the specification is silent, which isn't the same as no.

Read it against your own habits. If the first two columns matter to you, the choice narrows quickly. Availability depends on the phone: the camera guard build is for the Pro iPhones named above, MagSafe builds are for iPhone only, and Pixel models get Tough only.

Protective features by YOONIG build, from the maker's specifications
BuildRaised edgesLayersCornersCamera
ToughYes, screen and cameraTwo: polycarbonate shell, TPU linerNot statedRaised camera edge
MagSafe compatibleYesTwo: polycarbonate shell, TPU linerNot statedNot stated
MagSafe + camera guardYes, around the cameraTwo: TPU frame, polycarbonate backAir-cushioned, reinforced bumpersSurround built into the frame
ClearNot statedPolycarbonate back with TPU sidesCushioned TPU sidesNot stated
SlimSlightOne: polycarbonate shellNot statedNot stated
Card holderNot statedOne: polycarbonate shell with a card slotNot statedNot stated
SiliconeAround the lensesOne: solid siliconeNot statedCovers around the lenses

What no case does, and how to read protection claims

A case leaves the screen open, so a direct hit to the glass from a key or a stone is outside its job. That's what a screen protector is for, and do screen protectors work explains their limits. A standard case also adds nothing to water resistance; that comes from the phone, and it varies by model, as our guide to which iPhones are waterproof shows.

A case can even cause damage if it's neglected. Sand and grit that work their way inside sit between the case and the phone and rub with every movement. Apple's cleaning advice for its own cases is to take the phone out and wipe the inside as well as the outside with a soft, slightly damp, lint-free cloth (Apple: How to clean your Apple products). Do that every few weeks, more often after the beach.

When a product page quotes a drop height or a test standard, ask four things before you give it weight:

  • What height, and onto what surface? A fall onto plywood and a fall onto concrete are different events.
  • How many drops, and in which orientations? Corners, edges and faces behave differently.
  • Who ran the test: an independent lab, or the seller?
  • Was it this exact case for this exact phone model, or a similar one?
  • What counted as a pass: a working phone, or unbroken glass?
  • If none of that is stated, treat the claim as decoration. We'd sooner publish no number than one we can't answer these questions about.

Frequently asked questions

Are phone cases actually protective?

Yes, when they're designed for it. Raised edges keep glass off flat surfaces, a soft inner layer takes the shock and a rigid shell spreads it. A thin single-layer case mostly protects against scratches.

What are the best phone cases for drops?

Look for a two-layer build with raised screen and camera edges and cushioned corners, made for your exact model. In our range that describes Tough, MagSafe compatible and, for supported Pro iPhones, MagSafe + camera guard.

Do you publish a drop-test rating for your cases?

No. We don't have a figure we can fully stand behind, so we describe how each case is built and leave out numbers we can't verify.

Does a thicker case always protect better?

Not by itself. Where the material sits matters more than how much there is: a lip around the glass and cushioning at the corners do more than extra bulk on the flat of the back.

Does the case need to be made for my exact phone?

Yes. Raised edges and camera surrounds only work if they line up with the screen and lenses, and those positions change between models, even ones with similar names.

Find the builds we make for your exact model

Shop the story

Keep reading